‘Open Veins of Latin America’, written by Eduardo Galeano, has become a classic that turns fifty this year. It is a detailed and compact account of Latin America’s colonial history. After the military coup in Uruguay, it was banned and Galeano was forced into exile. The book is still relevant today.
Eduardo Galeano’s book can be accessed here.
In Galeano’s book, we follow five centuries of exceptional exploitation. First it was gold, silver and diamonds, later sugar, cocoa, cotton, rubber, fruit and eventually also oil. In order to extract the riches, the indigenous peoples were exploited in the cruel work in the mines and when the Indigenous peoples were no longer enough, slaves from the African continent were consumed on the plantations.
There is a big difference between the history of North and Latin America. The colonisers in North America came to build new lives, albeit on stolen land, and then broke free from the British crown. The colonisers of Latin America instead emptied the continent of its riches. Galeano describes it this way:
“For the north of America had no gold or silver, no Indian civilizations with dense concentrations of people already organized for work…”
While North America was filled with workers and peasants who had become obsolete in Europe, the capitalists in Latin America had a huge and cheap labour reserve in the form of the Indigenous peoples and slaves.
The exploitation of the riches of Latin America meant jobs, development and prosperity in Europe and North America, but not for the people of Latin America. The slave trade laid the foundation for these
“The exploitation of European conquerors resulted not only in a genocide, but in many parallel genocides in which entire civilisations were wiped out.”
In addition to leading to the horrific and systematic annihilation of people, it also led to cultural and scientific destruction and an ecological disaster. At the same time, the success of each raw material was short-lived. Soon another continent produced the same goods cheaper, faster and more efficiently, and the collapse soon became a fact. North America took over cotton production and Ghana, cocoa production. At the same time, all attempts at domestic industry were thwarted by imported goods.
“Commercial agents from Manchester, Glasgow, and Liverpool toured Argentina and copied Santiagan and Córdoban ponchos and Corrientes leather goods, as well as the local wooden stirrups. Argentine ponchos cost seven pesos, Yorkshire ones three. The world’s most advanced textile industry won at a gallop over the products of native looms, and it was the same with boots, spurs, iron grill work, bridles, and even nails.”
Paraguay stands out. In the middle of South America, without coasts, here was a country with its own industries without foreign profiteers. A strong state instead of a puppet bourgeoisie laid the foundation for the economy. There was development and some form of prosperity instead of unfavourable free trade with Europe or the United States. This example was not allowed to continue. In a six-year war fought on three fronts, Paraguay was crushed by the late 1800s with the help of capital from England. More than 60% of the population died, and the country was left in ruins. Even today, Paraguay is a poor country where inequality, instability and corruption characterise the country.
A country that bases its entire economy on raw material exports without industries or refining is sensitive to the whims of the market. We saw this in 2016 when commodity prices fell and countries such as Argentina, Brazil and Venezuela plunged with them. In ‘Open Veins of Latin America’, Galeano describes in detail how the continent is still a raw material producer and never gets the largest share of the pie:
“With petroleum, as with coffee or meat, rich countries profit more from the work of consuming it than do poor countries from the work of producing it.”
Higher coffee prices lead to greater profits, but not to higher wages. Lower coffee prices lower workers’ incomes in a single devastating blow. Exports go hand in hand with hunger. The children eat soil to keep anemia away, while profits flow freely out of the continent.
In El Salvador, a quarter of the population died because of vitamin deficiencies, while a handful of capitalists made their fortunes on coffee exports. Galeano’s book is full of heart-breaking examples, but he never gets sentimental. There is a ridiculous paradox in that the most fertile, richest regions are those that are thrown into abysmal poverty and famine. The land that could feed so many is bled dry when the next in-demand commodity is planted in huge monocultures.
There is no room for food production; instead, food was imported from other less fertile places to maximise short-term profits. In November this year, the UN warned that the number of hungry people in Latin America has risen by 30 percent since 2019. About 9% of the population in Latin America and the Caribbean go hungry, reports Al Jazeera.
“Latin America is a Pandora’s box; the tortured subcontinent’s capacity to spring surprises is never exhausted.”
In addition to the direct violence, forced labour and starvation, viral infections, transported across the sea by the colonisers, killed large sections of the Indigenous peoples. The coronavirus pandemic has shown how, even in recent years, Indigenous peoples are still marginalised in Latin America. Many work as housekeepers, nannies, caretakers and so on at the homes of well-to-do families in the big cities.
When the pandemic struck with full force, many of them were without work and had to return to their home villages; with them, they brought infection. In otherwise isolated places with an aging population and long distances to hospitals and doctors, the virus spread rapidly. The isolation that could have been a help in escaping the pandemic instead became a death sentence. The mortality rate among those who have received covid-19 among Indigenous peoples in Brazil is 9.1%; the corresponding figure for the rest of the population is 5.2 percent.
At the same time, the pandemic has created further economic instability in the region. Latin America is one of the most unequal parts of the world. And it is the Indigenous peoples and the descendants of the slaves who still face by far the worst situation.
Just as exploitation and colonisation are ingrained in the last 500 years of Latin American history, so too is resistance, and Galeano shows this in his book. The first major slave revolt occurred as early as 1522 when the slaves rose up against Christopher Columbus’s son, Diego Columbus. It was the first revolt, but far from the last.
During the 1600s, slaves who escaped built their own society, Palmares, on the east coast of Brazil. In Palmares, hunger did not exist. A variety of crops were grown there that kept the approximately 10,000-strong community self-sufficient, unlike the regions with sugar cane.
Several of the revolts have had land redistribution as one of the most important reforms on the agenda. Artiga’s vision of a united Latin America where Indigenous peoples regained their right to land is perhaps the oldest. Here are the seeds of a dream of a completely different society. A life free from oppression and violence where wealth is distributed equally.
The ten-year struggle in Mexico in 1910–20 fought by Indigenous peasants led by Emiliano Zapata carries lessons of organisation: nationalisation, land expropriation, people’s councils and elected judges and police.
It is a brutal story that Galeano describes. Where there is resistance, it is beaten down in blood — with executions, persecution and torture. The counter-revolution is usually bloodier than the revolution, and the capitalists, who, even in ordinary cases, have no problem building their wealth on corpses, have not hesitated to use weapons when their power is threatened in Latin America.
In 1968, just before the Olympics, students from the growing student movement in Tlatelolco, Mexico, demonstrated against poverty and hunger. The military and paramilitaries opened fire on the demonstration, which ended in a massacre. What Galeano did not know when he wrote ‘Open Veins of Latin America’ was that even during the Tlatelolco massacre, the United States, through the CIA, was involved.
Violence continues to be present throughout Latin America. In Mexico, relatives of the 43 students who disappeared 7 years ago are still looking for their bodies. In Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, nearly 60 shootings with three or more dead were reported in 2021. The majority of the shootings have taken place during police interventions that are more like pure executions.
Capitalism has no inherent intelligence of its own — on the contrary, it follows an absurdly illogical path. In Cuba, hardwood forests were burned down to make way for sugar cane. At the same time, Cuba became the largest importer of wood products from the United States.
The story is not over. The veins are still open. Today, the newfound craze for avocados is draining Chile’s drinking water, quinoa plantations are depleting the soil in Bolivia, and the heavy use of pesticides for bananas is killing plantation workers in Nicaragua prematurely.
At the same time, the lungs of the world in the Amazon are being ravaged to make way for soy, and so the devastation continues.
But the resistance is alive. In Brazil, Paraguay and Bolivia, Indigenous peoples are fighting deforestation and environmental toxins. Another 50 years of exploitation, imperialism and movements needed to be accounted for. When the book was written, the labour movement was on the rise. There was optimism and a belief in the future. This was before Augusto Pinochet and the US-backed military dictatorships in South America. Left winds have come and gone. Reformist step-by-step attempts to abolish the power of capital and the landowners have been made and thwarted.
Eduardo Galeano experienced the fall of the dictatorship in Uruguay and also the victory of the left. But not how the right came back, and how the welfare state that existed for a short time and that gave the working class a much-needed breathing space is collapsing.
The tug-of-war between the capitalist upper class and the workers is constantly taking on new forms. The United States continues to use Latin America as its playground and now China is also in the game. Everything has changed, nothing has changed. The book is still an important historical review of Latin America’s colonial history and today, it would need one, or perhaps, two sequels.
When the book was written, the Soviet Union and a Stalinist bloc still existed as a rival counterweight to US imperialism. The military dictatorships in Uruguay, Chile and Argentina had not yet crushed the labour movement, which was on the rise in the early 1970s. The rotten flower of neoliberalism had not yet blossomed in Chile, nor the huge protests that took place in 2019 as a result of neoliberal policies in particular.
If the book had been written today, even the enormous migrations of people that are currently taking place from Latin America and the Caribbean to the United States would have had their own chapter. Likewise, the wave of women’s movements for the right to abortion and against violence against women that has swept across Latin America, and which has also swept over to other continents.
Much has happened since 1971, but the exploitation of both Latin America’s nature and peoples persists and so does the resistance. Only when the working class leaves the arena of parliamentarism and reformism and unites across national borders to overthrow the slavedrivers can the veins lead blood to the heart and feed the whole of Latin America.